EPA DRAFT RISK ASSESSMENT SAYS GASOLINE ADDITIVE (MTBE) IS A LIKELY HUMAN CARCINOGENJul 12, 2005 | www.newsinferno.com MTBE, or methyl tertiary butyl ether, is a gasoline additive which has been used since 1979. It was originally used to help gasoline burn more smoothly and efficiently after lead was phased out as an additive. At room temperature, MTBE is a volatile, flammable and colorless liquid that is more soluble in water than most other gasoline components.
Starting in 1992, oil companies started adding MTBE to gasoline to improve combustion and decrease harmful carbon monoxide emissions from motor vehicles, especially in the winter months. The goal was to improve the air quality in urban areas and to help cities meet Clean Air Act standards.
Exposure to MTBE can occur when pumping gasoline, living near bulk gasoline loading and unloading facilities or near facilities that can leak gasoline from underground or above-ground storage containers thereby contaminating drinking water.
In most of these situations, the most important form of exposure is the inhalation of MTBE-contaminated air. However, it is also absorbed through the contact with the skin. Contamination of the groundwater near storage facilities can also result in exposure from the tap water.
Other sources of MTBE in the environment (and potentially into drinking water sources) are associated with gasoline spillage when fuel is transported or transferred, leaking gasoline pipelines, spills at gas stations, automobile accidents where fuel tanks are ruptured, improper disposal of "old" gasoline, and emissions from older and inefficient two-stroke marine engines.
Drinking water in at least 1,800 water systems in 29 states is contaminated to some degree by MTBE.
In a news release yesterday, the Environmental working Group (EWG) announced (http://www.ewg.org/issues/mtbe/20050711/index.php) that a draft risk assessment by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) contained language linking “MTBE to cancers such as leukemia and lymphoma.”
Although this would represent a significant shift in the EPA’s position, the draft has been circulating within the agency for review purposes for over a year. It must still be “signed off on” by all EPA divisions and “go through external review.” EWG states that people within the EPA “have been trying to get this out of the agency forever.”
Currently, there is a debate in Congress over legislation that would compel the petroleum industry to clean up the problem it created as a result of underground contamination from leaking storage facilities and pipelines. The estimates cost of such a massive cleanup range from $25 billion to as high as $85 billion.
The House of Representatives has passed an energy bill that would prohibit municipalities and water systems from suing MTBE makers for “knowingly manufacturing and distributing a defective product.” This is despite evidence that the oil industry already knew in 1979 that MTBE was a threat to water supplies.
EWG President, Ken Cook, observed: "We knew the idea to exempt MTBE makers from lawsuits was bad news for taxpayers. Now EPA is learning how dangerous it would be for public health. No matter how the risk assessment finally comes out, this is clearly not the time to be letting the makers of this chemical off the hook."