Parker Waichman LLP

Medtronic ruling may be catalyst for settling

Medtronic’s failed attempt to dismiss more than 300 lawsuits. Medtronic’s failed attempt to dismiss more than 300 lawsuits over a recalled

Medtronic ruling

Medtronic’s failed attempt to dismiss more than 300 lawsuits. Medtronic’s failed attempt to dismiss more than 300 lawsuits over a recalled heart defibrillator model could lead to out-of-court settlements, a legal expert said Wednesday.

Medtronic said it intends to appeal the Tuesday decision by U.S. District Judge James Rosenbaum, but the ruling’s firm language may motivate the company to negotiate an end to the litigation, a law professor said.

“The plaintiff certainly has some ammunition to work with now,” said David Prince of the William Mitchell College of Law. “Generally speaking, having to face the prospect of trying cases is a good thing for the plaintiff and a bad thing for the defendant.”

Plaintiffs say Medtronic knew a battery in one model of its implantable cardioverter defibrillators

Plaintiffs say Medtronic knew a battery in one model of its implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICD) was defective almost two years before it informed the Food and Drug Administration and alerted doctors about the potential for the device to lose its electrical charge prematurely.

Medtronic claimed the lawsuits are baseless, or preempted, because the device had passed a rigorous FDA approval process. Rosenbaum ruled that the preemption model did not apply in this case and that the cases could proceed. He referred to the defective ICD as a “medical Trojan horse” containing flawed components.

Lawyers for the ICD patients were buoyed by the ruling.

The overall number of lawsuits appears relatively small

“This opens the courthouse doors to go forward and settle our claims,” said Robert (Randy) Hopper, a plaintiff’s attorney with the Minneapolis law firm Zimmerman Reed.

Wall Street, however, seemed to respond with a yawn Wednesday to news that Medtronic failed in its bid to dismiss the lawsuits. Shares rose slightly in the morning and declined slightly in the afternoon the day after the ruling in Minneapolis. The stock closed at $52.73, up 8 cents.

Thomas Gunderson, an analyst for Piper Jaffray & Co., said the ruling will have “little impact” on Medtronic.

“The overall number of lawsuits appears relatively small,” Gunderson said. “There seems to be no serious consequences or deaths due to the recalled battery issue.
Investors are not likely to attach importance to this decision.”

risk is inherent in the business of medical devices

David Heupel, portfolio manager for Thrivent Investment’s Large Cap Growth Fund, said risk is inherent in the business of medical devices.

“That comes with the territory,” Heupel said. “These are complicated devices. There’s no such thing as a perfect implantable defibrillator.”

In his ruling, Rosenbaum said lawyers for the ICD recipients developed “credible evidence” that Medtronic continued to ship and sell devices with defective batteries after it discovered the defect.

Rosenbaum also wrote that it “defies logic” to contend that Congress meant to preempt device makers from lawsuits after it received FDA approval for a product. “If the court adopted Medtronic’s view, once a medical device manufacturer obtains approval, it would be insulated from liability even if it chose to conceal data from the FDA,” he wrote.

Rosenbaum concluded that lawyers for the ICD patients have produced enough facts to demonstrate they have a case suitable for trial.

“From this evidence, a reasonable trier of fact could find Medtronic knew of this defect for a substantial period prior to advising the FDA of the defect,” Rosenbaum wrote.

Need Legal Help Regarding Medtronic ruling?

The personal injury attorneys at Parker Waichman offer free, no-obligation case evaluations. For more information, fill out our online form or call 1-800-YOURLAWYER (1-800-968-7529).

More battery-related cases:

What Our Clients Say About Us
We have worked with thousands of clients and we appreciate them and their positive reviews. Here are just a few recent client reviews...
5 Star Reviews 150
Gina Viti..My Lawyer with PW LLP.., Gina is an extra special person with Neverending patience..I am OLD SCHOOL..She had to walk me through all necessary steps and did so with knowledge and kind consideration..Not easy to deal with an elder..Gina miraculously got my HEARING going over the phone..Gina is a thorough all encompassing Lawyer..I so much appreciate her and will never forget her
Dorothy Zaharatos
4 weeks ago
5 Star Reviews 150
I found them in the yellow pages online. I had a bad care accident and out of work for months. They walked me through the legal process and explained to me what my rights were. Thank you for being there, things are better now.
Gordon Rios
7 years ago
5 Star Reviews 150
Mrs. Josama is phenomenal! She was extremely thorough, attentive, and knowledgeable.
Karema Brown
4 years ago

Why Choose Us to Help You?

We Take Care of Everything
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
No Recovery = No Legal Fees
We work on a contingency-fee basis, meaning that we only get paid from a portion of your settlement or jury award. If you don't get compensation, you owe us nothing.
Decades of Experience
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
Respected by Our Peers
Judges, insurance adjusters, and fellow attorneys all speak highly of our skills, and we've earned numerous accolades, including a flawless rating from AVVO.
We Have Many Locations To Serve You
We have the experience and the skilled litigators to win your case. Contact us and speak with a real attorney who can help you.
Long Island – Nassau
Parker Waichman LLP
6 Harbor Park Drive
Port Washington, NY 11050
Long Island – Suffolk
Parker Waichman LLP
201 Old Country Road – Suite 145
Melville, NY 11747
New York
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038
Queens
Parker Waichman LLP
118-35 Queens Boulevard, Suite 400
Forest Hills, NY 11375
Brooklyn
Parker Waichman LLP
300 Cadman Plaza West
One Pierrepont Plaza, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
New Jersey
Parker Waichman LLP
80 Main Street, Suite 265
West Orange, NJ 07052
Florida
Parker Waichman LLP
27299 Riverview Center Boulevard
Suite 108
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Nationwide Service
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038