Parker Waichman LLP

No Justice for Plaintiffs in Little Noticed Supreme Court Decision

Supreme Court Issued Implication For Plaintiffs. A Supreme Court decision issued in May is proving to have dangerous implications for plaintiffs in civil lawsuits.  According to a New York Times article, the decision in  Ashcroft vs. Iqbal has made it far easier – in fact, too easy – for  federal judges to dismiss civil lawsuits long […]

Supreme Court Decision

Supreme Court Issued Implication For Plaintiffs. A Supreme Court decision issued in May is proving to have dangerous implications for plaintiffs in civil lawsuits.  According to a New York Times article, the decision in  Ashcroft vs. Iqbal has made it far easier – in fact, too easy – for  federal judges to dismiss civil lawsuits long before plaintiffs even have a chance to be heard.

In Ashcroft vs. Iqbal, a Muslim plaintiff had claimed that he suffered abuse while imprisoned on immigration charges in New York after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. 

In a 5 to 4 decision, the high court overturned a ruling that the plaintiff, who was imprisoned more than a year after the attacks, could  proceed with his lawsuit against former Attorney General John Ashcroft and FBI Director Robert Mueller.

Satisfy a skeptical judicial gatekeeper

According to The New York Times, what was little-noticed about  Ashcroft vs Iqbal is that it establishes a difficult new standard plaintiffs filing civil lawsuits must meet before they can even get past the courthouse door. 

In his majority opinion, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wrote that: “Determining whether a complaint states a plausible claim for relief requires the reviewing court to draw on its judicial experience and common sense.”

According to The New York Times, Justice Kennedy’s words mean  a  civil lawsuit must now “satisfy a skeptical judicial gatekeeper.”  Prior to this ruling, plaintiffs only had to file a basic complaint.  To dismiss a suit – established in a 1957 Supreme Court decision – a federal judge had to determine “beyond doubt” that a plaintiff had no case.

The old standards served plaintiffs well, because in most cases, the facts surrounding an act of wrongdoing – whether it involves employment discrimination, defective products or fraud – are closely guarded by  defendants. 

Even with a bare-bones complaint, plaintiffs were entitled to examine a defendant’s records, and question key individuals.  Through this discovery process, the outrageous, deliberate and unlawful conduct of many a defendant saw the light of day.

But under Iqbal, that process has been undermined

But under Iqbal, that process has been undermined.  According to The New York Times, the decision instructs lower court judges to dismiss lawsuits that “strike them as implausible.”   That’s a pretty loose – and dangerous – standard for judges to follow. 

Stephen B. Burbank of the University of Pennsylvania Law School told the Times that the Iqbal decision is “a blank check for federal judges to get rid of cases they disfavor.”

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who dissented from the majority opinion,  has characterized Iqbal as important and dangerous, The New York Times said.  Speaking to a group of federal judges last month, Justice Ginsburg said Iqbal “messed up the federal rules” governing civil litigation.

Already, Iqbal is having a huge impact on lawsuits in this country.  According to The New York Times, lower courts have cited it 500 times since the decision was published in May by the Supreme Court.

Lawsuit involving everything from employment discrimination to securities fraud  have been dismissed before they even got off the ground. Sadly, under Iqbal, it seems clear that many plaintiffs with legitimate grievances will never have their day in court.

Need Legal Help?

The personal injury attorneys at Parker Waichman LLP offer free, no-obligation case evaluations. For more information, fill out our online contact form or call 1-800-YOURLAWYER (1-800-968-7529).

What Our Clients Say About Us
We have worked with thousands of clients and we appreciate them and their positive reviews. Here are just a few recent client reviews...
5 Star Reviews 150
It was great an professional experience! Really i recomend.
Santiago Lopez
4 months ago
5 Star Reviews 150
I am satisfied with the service I received from Parker Waichman LLP, I am submitting a review of the excellent service that I received from Ms. Benita Rollis. I depended on her expertise regarding legal matters. She was very attentive to my concerns and answered any questions that I had. Ms. Rollis has great customer service skills that includes a positive attitude and patience . She is a valuable asset to Parker Waichman LLP. Sincerely, Ms. Angela Jones
Angela Jones
3 years ago
5 Star Reviews 150
i was lucky to have had Benita Rollis help me with my claim. She answered all my questions and helped me throughout this long process. She was always helpful and got back to me in a timely manner.
Tommy
3 years ago

Why Choose Us to Help You?

We Take Care of Everything
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
No Recovery = No Legal Fees
We work on a contingency-fee basis, meaning that we only get paid from a portion of your settlement or jury award. If you don't get compensation, you owe us nothing.
Decades of Experience
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
Respected by Our Peers
Judges, insurance adjusters, and fellow attorneys all speak highly of our skills, and we've earned numerous accolades, including a flawless rating from AVVO.
We Have Many Locations To Serve You
We have the experience and the skilled litigators to win your case. Contact us and speak with a real attorney who can help you.
Long Island – Nassau
Parker Waichman LLP
6 Harbor Park Drive
Port Washington, NY 11050
Long Island – Suffolk
Parker Waichman LLP
201 Old Country Road – Suite 145
Melville, NY 11747
New York
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038
Queens
Parker Waichman LLP
118-35 Queens Boulevard, Suite 400
Forest Hills, NY 11375
Brooklyn
Parker Waichman LLP
300 Cadman Plaza West
One Pierrepont Plaza, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
New Jersey
Parker Waichman LLP
80 Main Street, Suite 265
West Orange, NJ 07052
Florida
Parker Waichman LLP
27299 Riverview Center Boulevard
Suite 108
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Nationwide Service
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038