Driving with a Medical Condition May Be Deemed an Act of Negligence

Driving while medically impaired

For many people, the ability to drive is one of the fundamental tenets of independence.  Therefore, it is difficult to accept that it may not be safe to continue to operate a vehicle in light of a medical condition.  A person may continue to drive even though he poses a threat to other drivers because he does not want to give up the freedom that comes with driving. However, this decision may have devastating consequences.  When the driver gets into a car crash as the result of his or her medical condition, the question of what he or she knew about his condition becomes a critical part of the analysis about his negligence.

When a driver with a medical condition causes a serious accident, there are two different scenarios:

• The driver was not aware of his condition or its severity – A driver who is unaware that he has a medical condition that could lead to loss of control of a vehicle may not be liable if he suffers from an emergency and causes an accident.
• The driver was aware of his condition and chose to drive anyway – When a person with a known medical condition decides to get behind the wheel of his vehicle despite the possibility of losing control as the result of a medical emergency, he may be negligent, depending on the totality of the circumstances.

When looking at a case like this, it is important to determine what the person with the medical condition knew, the statistical likelihood of a medical event that could impact the person’s ability to drive, and what precautions had been taken.  If the driver knew about the medical condition, or should have known based on available information, then he is responsible for the harm that he caused when he got into an accident as a result of a medical emergency.  There are a number of medical conditions that may cause a loss of the capacity to maintain control of a vehicle, including:

• Epilepsy;
• Diabetes;
• Narcolepsy;
• Various heart conditions; and
• Other medical conditions that lead to incapacitation or loss of consciousness.

There is a defense to this type of accident, which is known as the sudden medical emergency defense.  In order to effectively assert this defense, the driver would need to show the following:

• The driver lost consciousness without warning, leaving no time to react to the medical event in time to prevent an accident;
• The driver’s loss of consciousness or ability to control the vehicle was due to a previously unknown medical condition – the driver must be able to prove that the emergency event was no foreseeable; and
• The medical emergency was the direct cause of the accident because it resulted in a loss of control.

In order to prove negligence in this type of case, the analysis is going to focus on the element of foreseeability.  If the driver had a reason to suspect that he or she could cause an accident because of a sudden medical event, then he had the obligation to make other transportation arrangements.  If he decided that driving was more important than the safety of other drivers who might be unfortunate enough to share the road with him, then he or she could be responsible for all the harm that he caused, including medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other associated costs.

A person who was injured in a car accident faces the stress of recovery as well as dealing with the financial and emotional turmoil that comes with many crashes.  At Parker Waichman LLP, we pride ourselves on helping our clients pursue the results that they deserve.  If you would like to discuss your potential auto accident case with our office, contact us today at 1-800-YOUR-LAWYER (1-800-968-7529).

More on NYC accidents:

• Personal Injury Lawyer in NYC
• New York Accident Personal Injury Lawyers
• Car Accident Lawyers in NYC
• New York City Pedestrian Accident Attorney
• New York Truck Accident Injury Lawyers
• Motorcycle Accident Lawyer in New York