Parker Waichman LLP

California Supreme Court Upholds Right to Sue for Intentional Misuse of “Organic” Label

The California Supreme Court issued a groundbreaking unanimous decision upholding the rights of consumers to sue an herb grower for intentionally mislabeling conventionally grown herbs as “organic” and charging the premium price that organic products command. The court rejected a California appeals court’s conclusion that the federal Organic Food Production Act (OFPA) preempted the consumers’ […]

The California Supreme Court issued a groundbreaking unanimous decision upholding the rights of consumers to sue an herb grower for intentionally mislabeling conventionally grown herbs as “organic” and charging the premium price that organic products command.

The court rejected a California appeals court’s conclusion that the federal Organic Food Production Act (OFPA) preempted the consumers’ claims. The high court held that lawsuits like this one are not preempted because they affirmatively support OFPA’s core goal of enhancing consumer confidence in meaningful organic labels, according to PublicJustice.net.

Associate Justice Kathryn Werdegar, writing for the unanimous court, said, “tate lawsuits alleging intentional organic mislabeling promote, rather than hinder, Congress’s purposes and objectives.” The decision states, “ermitting state consumer fraud actions would advance, not impair, goals. Substitution fraud, intentionally marketing products as organic that have been grown conventionally, undermines the assurances the USDA Organic label is intended to provide. Conversely, the prosecution of such fraud, whether by public prosecutors where resources and state laws permit, or through civil suits by individuals or groups of consumers, can only serve to deter mislabeling and enhance consumer confidence.”

The federal Eighth Circuit, in an organic milk marketing case, found consumer fraud claims preempted by federal law. The California Supreme Court distinguishes the dairy case on its facts, making clear that “where a grower knowingly and intentionally sells some conventional herbs under an organic label and at an organic premium price,” consumer fraud claims based on such conduct complement the core purposes of OFPA, according to Public Justice.

The case is important, Public Justice says, because consumers were cheated when they paid organic prices for conventionally grown products. When consumers pay more for food labeled organic, the food should in fact be organic. The case also matters for the organic industry itself. Organic growing methods are more labor intensive and organic farmers do not receive the federal subsidies conventional farms receive. For these and other reasons, organic produce costs more than conventional produce. But many people choose to pay extra for food that is produced without growth hormones, chemical fertilizers, and pesticides. If growers mislabel conventional produce as organic—and profit from charging premium prices—they will eventually drive their honest organic competitors out of business, Public Justice asserts.

Permitting consumer fraud lawsuits such as the California suit to go forward not only helps consumers get what they pay for when they choose organic produce but also levels the playing field for all growers.

 

What Our Clients Say About Us
We have worked with thousands of clients and we appreciate them and their positive reviews. Here are just a few recent client reviews...
5 Star Reviews 150
This law firm is awesome. Alex and Cathy did there thing. As long as I been with them I still don't know Cathy's name. They were NEVER to busy. The young ladies in the front lobby very nice. When they would see me they knew my name. That's how I knew I had the right law firm. Thank you for easing my mind.
yolanda keitt
a year ago
5 Star Reviews 150
Amazing law firm I was extremely pleased with my service! Jorge Peniche is the best
Lino Castillo
4 years ago
5 Star Reviews 150
I am very happy and lucky to have highly professional help of Parker Waichman LLP staff. In particular, I want to express my thankfulness to Cristina Morace for her patience, diligence and kindness which I saw from her for many years, and which softened pain and sorrow of losses. THANK YOU!
Marina Perlov
3 months ago

Why Choose Us to Help You?

We Take Care of Everything
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
No Recovery = No Legal Fees
We work on a contingency-fee basis, meaning that we only get paid from a portion of your settlement or jury award. If you don't get compensation, you owe us nothing.
Decades of Experience
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
Respected by Our Peers
Judges, insurance adjusters, and fellow attorneys all speak highly of our skills, and we've earned numerous accolades, including a flawless rating from AVVO.
We Have Many Locations To Serve You
We have the experience and the skilled litigators to win your case. Contact us and speak with a real attorney who can help you.
Long Island – Nassau
Parker Waichman LLP
6 Harbor Park Drive
Port Washington, NY 11050
Long Island – Suffolk
Parker Waichman LLP
201 Old Country Road – Suite 145
Melville, NY 11747
New York
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038
Queens
Parker Waichman LLP
118-35 Queens Boulevard, Suite 400
Forest Hills, NY 11375
Brooklyn
Parker Waichman LLP
300 Cadman Plaza West
One Pierrepont Plaza, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
New Jersey
Parker Waichman LLP
80 Main Street, Suite 265
West Orange, NJ 07052
Florida
Parker Waichman LLP
27299 Riverview Center Boulevard
Suite 108
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Nationwide Service
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038