Parker Waichman LLP

Bishop O’Brien Failed The Faithful

Bishop O’Brien Matter of Resignation. Whether he does depends, among other things, on whether he believes he serves just the institutional Catholic Church or the faith and the faithful. Catholics used to be able to believe all these were one and the same. But it’s clear that not all of us can find it either […]

Bishop O’Brien

Bishop O’Brien Matter of Resignation. Whether he does depends, among other things, on whether he believes he serves just the institutional Catholic Church or the faith and the faithful.

Catholics used to be able to believe all these were one and the same. But it’s clear that not all of us can find it either in our hearts or faith to believe in the unity of these concepts any longer.

This is the biggest tragedy to come out of the church’s sordid sex scandals. But this distinction between church and Catholics and the faith is important to the specific matter of resignation.

If O’Brien clings to the notion that he has faithfully served the institution, he can make a credible case that he shouldn’t resign. That’s because it’s become abundantly clear that bishops or priests who told families of molested children to shut up and go away were simply following accepted church policy.

In practice, this policy put the church, as merely a collection of edifice, hierarchy and image, above the church as a representation and practitioner of beliefs and as a moral beacon.

Bishops or priests who failed to report allegations of molestation to civil authorities were being good soldiers. If they arranged or helped to arrange the transfer of problem priests to other parishes to molest again, they were most probably just following explicit or implicit orders.

But in the end, this is an inadequate defense.

Even in war, soldiers who commit or abet atrocities, even under orders, have not been immune from prosecution. And they never should be, even if on the winning side.

Shielding molester priests to molest again is the Catholic equivalent of atrocity.

Some, of course, will argue that the case against O’Brien has not been completely made.

And it’s true. O’Brien has not been convicted of a thing and may never be. We should note, however, that neither has Cardinal Bernard Law of Boston.

But whether he resigns really has nothing to do with whether he will ever be convicted of criminal wrongdoing. This is a matter of whether O’Brien will ever be able to exercise the kind of moral leadership the local church needs, given what has happened on his watch and past church practice.

In any case, there comes a point when you really don’t need the validation of a criminal court to know that wrongs have been committed.

Molestations By Priests

Two families have come forward and alleged that they met with O’Brien about molestation by priests of their children and that he told them essentially to shut up. He allegedly assured them that the priests would be removed from their parishes.

This occurred shortly before O’Brien became bishop but while he was vicar general of the Phoenix Diocese and pastor at St. Catherine’s in Phoenix.

Both priests, the Revs. John Maurice Giandelone and Patrick Colleary, were transferred to other parishes, where they either molested or are suspected of molesting children.

O’Brien said through his attorney that he does not recall meeting with the family in the Giandelone case. Meanwhile, Giandelone, being extradited from Florida because of the new charges, reportedly acknowledged to county investigators sent to retrieve him that he met with O’Brien.

This indicates that O’Brien’s memory may be more than faulty. In this latest revelation, the molested child grew up to become a police officer.

So this is what we know or can reasonably surmise:

These two families are probably not lying.

Since he became bishop in 1982, the diocese has paid close to $2 million to settle 12 to 15 lawsuits involving allegations of sexual abuse or sexual harassment.

About 50 priests, former priests and church employees have been accused of criminal sexual misconduct with minors in the diocese in the last 30 years.

Altogether, this makes a damning case that the Phoenix Diocese has much to answer for. In any case, it needs to break with the past and with past practices. This is something O’Brien’s resignation could help speed along.

This is not a matter of seeking the proverbial pound of flesh. That’s the county attorney’s job.

It’s about getting on with the much needed work of healing.

Need Legal Help Regarding Bishop O’Brien?

The personal injury attorneys at Parker Waichman LLP offer free, no-obligation case evaluations. For more information, fill out our online contact form or call 1-800-YOURLAWYER (1-800-968-7529).

What Our Clients Say About Us
We have worked with thousands of clients and we appreciate them and their positive reviews. Here are just a few recent client reviews...
5 Star Reviews 150
I am very grateful to the Waichman LLP law firm for all their help throughout the process. In my case, they were very kind, especially my friend Jorge Peniche, who was very attentive to my case. I am more satisfied with the final decision in my case. Thank you very much.
Silverwolf Romano
a year ago
5 Star Reviews 150
Positive: Quality
Juan Jerez
3 years ago
5 Star Reviews 150
I love my lawyers
Eliseo Morales Herranz
6 years ago

Why Choose Us to Help You?

We Take Care of Everything
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
No Recovery = No Legal Fees
We work on a contingency-fee basis, meaning that we only get paid from a portion of your settlement or jury award. If you don't get compensation, you owe us nothing.
Decades of Experience
Your situation is stressful enough: Let us take on the deadlines, paperwork, investigation, and litigation. We'll handle every detail so you don't have to worry.
Respected by Our Peers
Judges, insurance adjusters, and fellow attorneys all speak highly of our skills, and we've earned numerous accolades, including a flawless rating from AVVO.
We Have Many Locations To Serve You
We have the experience and the skilled litigators to win your case. Contact us and speak with a real attorney who can help you.
Long Island – Nassau
Parker Waichman LLP
6 Harbor Park Drive
Port Washington, NY 11050
Long Island – Suffolk
Parker Waichman LLP
201 Old Country Road – Suite 145
Melville, NY 11747
New York
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038
Queens
Parker Waichman LLP
118-35 Queens Boulevard, Suite 400
Forest Hills, NY 11375
Brooklyn
Parker Waichman LLP
300 Cadman Plaza West
One Pierrepont Plaza, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
New Jersey
Parker Waichman LLP
80 Main Street, Suite 265
West Orange, NJ 07052
Florida
Parker Waichman LLP
27299 Riverview Center Boulevard
Suite 108
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Nationwide Service
Parker Waichman LLP
59 Maiden Lane, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10038