People who were injured by cosmetics National law firm Parker Waichman has successfully represented people who were injured by cosmetics and personal care products, from soaps, lotions, sunscreens, cosmetics, and toothpaste, to hair dyes and hair relaxers. The firm is investigating potential connections between the use of hair dyes and hair relaxers and an increased risk of breast cancer.
Recent Studies Highlight Hair Dye Risks
The safety of hair dye products has been debated for many years, but a newly published study shows evidence of an increased risk of breast cancer in women who used certain hair dyes and hair relaxers, Science Times reports (Sciencetimes.com). Researchers from Rutgers University in New Jersey analyzed hair product data for African American and Caucasian women, taking into account such factors as the women’s social and economic backgrounds
WebMD reported on the study, which involved 4,285 women from New Jersey and New York: 2,280 with cancer (1,508 African American and 772 Caucasian women) and 2,005 controls (1,290 African American and 715 Caucasian). The women were asked about their use of hair products including dyes, chemical relaxers, and deep conditioning creams containing cholesterol or placenta. Cholesterol is marketed as a moisture restorer, and placenta is sold as a hair repair product.
In their analysis, the Rutgers researchers considered how long the women had used the hair dyes, the shade of the dye they used, and the woman’s race. The researchers adjusted their findings for such factors as age, education, and use of birth control pills. It is possible that some element of a woman’s lifestyle other than use of hair dyes and relaxers could affect her breast cancer risk.
The study was published in the June online issue of the journal Carcinogenesis.
African-American women surveyed were found to have 51 percent higher risk of breast cancer when the used dark brown or black hair dyes. Caucasian women who used chemical hair relaxers or straighteners were found to have a 74 percent higher cancer risk. The researchers say they see an “association” but this does not prove a direct connection between the use of hair dyes or relaxers and breast cancer.
Adana Llanos, the study’s lead researcher, who is an epidemiologist at the Rutgers Cancer Institute of New Jersey and Rutgers School of Public Health, explained, “Just because we found these associations doesn’t mean that if you dye your hair dark, or any color, you’re going to get breast cancer.” Llanos said it is not clear why the chemicals in hair products may boost cancer risk. But research suggests the risk may involve DNA damage or the body’s absorption of harmful chemicals. Darker dyes have different chemical formulas than lighter colors. The difference in ingredients in darker dyes may explain the increased cancer risk for those products. “More research is needed to determine specifically which compounds and chemicals are dangerous and even which specific consumer products and brands contain those chemicals,” Llanos said.
Llanos noted that we all regularly “encounter a variety of harmful exposures” over which we have no control and “we should limit or reduce the possibility of harmful exposures when we are able to do so.”
In addition to potential cancer risks, users have suffered skin reactions and hair damage. Hair relaxers have caused breakage and hair thinning. Women have reported that the products stunt hair growth and some women have also complained of scalp irritation, chemical burns to the scalp, scalp damage, or hair loss.
Permanent Hair Dye and Straighteners Could Cause Breast Cancer
WASHINGTON, D.C. — (December 9, 2019) A study released by the National Institutes of Health could make women rethink hair coloring and straightening with permanent chemicals. A study instituted by the National Institute of Environmental Health Services Epidemiology Division said that the chance that a woman might fall ill with breast cancer increases dramatically when she uses permanent chemicals to dye her hair or to straighten her hair. The chance of developing breast cancer escalates when the woman has more frequent treatments. One of the co-authors of the long-term project, who was interviewed by the Today Show, said that finding a correlation between dye, straighteners, and cancer is not the equivalent of causing cancer. The authors of the study acknowledged that more work needs to be done on the subject.
The hypothesis that chemicals used in permanent hair dyes and straighteners have been explored in the public health community for some time. One of the realities of trying to determine what causes breast cancer is the understanding that many genetic and environmental factors can cause breast cancer. However, the correlation found by scientists from this most recent study indicates that women should be cautious when choosing to use hair dye and straighteners even though many scientists urged consumers to be cautious about the results of the study and not jump to conclusions.
The study looked at 46,709 women who enrolled in the “Sister Study.” The cohort was comprised of women who had sisters with breast cancer but did not have cancer personally. The participants in the study responded to questions relating to their use of hair products. About 55 percent of all women said they used permanent hair dyes. Also, 75 percent of African-American females used a hair straightener. The reachers followed the cohort for a total of eight years. At the end of the eight-year period, 2,794 women received a diagnosis of breast cancer.
The researchers sifted through the data and determined that nine percent of women who use permanent dyes had an increased risk of breast cancer when compared to females who used none or temporary dyes.
Straighten has risks, as well. The chance of developing breast cancer increased by eighteen percent in women who used straighteners. The chance went as high as 31 percent when women used straighteners once every five weeks or so. Hairdressers are at risk of inhaling the chemicals from straighteners.
Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma Risk
Studies have investigated the relationship between the use of hair dyes and the risk of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL). Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma is a blood cancer that starts in white blood cells, which are part of the body’s immune system. But a pooled (combined) analysis of four case-control studies showed that women who began using hair dye before 1980 had a slightly (30%) increased risk of NHL compared with women who had never used hair dye, the National Cancer Institute reports. No such increased risk was seen for women who began using hair dye after 1980.
The pooled analysis included 4,461 women with NHL and 5,799 women who did not have NHL. The researchers obtained detailed information on hair dye use, including dates and duration of use. When the researchers analyzed the risks of several specific NHL subtypes, they found that hair dye users had increased risks of the subtypes follicular lymphoma and chronic lymphocytic leukemia/small lymphocytic lymphoma. For the most part, the increases were seen in women who began using hair dye before 1980. These results are consistent with the idea that earlier hair dyes were more carcinogenic, according to the National Cancer Institute. But the results may also reflect that women who began using dyes after 1980 have lower cumulative exposure levels or there has been insufficient time since first exposure for any increase in risk to have become apparent.
Hair Dyes and Cancer
In its web page on hair dyes and cancer risk, the National Cancer Institute explains that modern hair dyes fall into three types: permanent (or oxidative), semi-permanent, and temporary. Permanent hair dyes, which make up about 80 percent of currently marketed products, consist of colorless dye “intermediates” (chemicals called aromatic amines) and dye “couplers.” In the presence of hydrogen peroxide, the intermediates and couplers react with one another to form pigment molecules. Higher concentrations of intermediates are used to darker dye color formulas. Semi-permanent and temporary hair dyes are nonoxidative and include colored compounds that stain hair directly.
Researchers have studied the potential cancer risks of hair dyes and other hair products for decades. They have focused on the risks for bladder cancer, leukemia, and breast cancer. Studies have looked at the risks for both the women having their hair treated and for the hairdressers and salon workers exposed to the products daily.
The National Cancer Institute says that although some studies have linked the use of hair dyes with increased risks of certain cancers of the blood and bone marrow, such as non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL) and leukemia, other studies have not shown such links.
Early hair dye formulations contained chemicals, including aromatic amines that were found to cause cancer in animals. In the mid- to late 1970s, manufacturers changed the components in dye products to eliminate some of these chemicals. Researchers have not determined whether chemicals still used in hair dyes can cause cancer. But the National Cancer Institute warns that given the widespread use of hair dye products, even a small increase in cancer risk may have a considerable public health impact.
Health risks from hair dyes and hair relaxers are not limited to the women whose hair is treated. Some studies have found an increased risk of bladder cancer in hairdressers and barbers and salon workers, who are exposed to chemicals in the products they use. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), the cancer research arm of the World Health Organization, concluded that some of the chemicals these workers are exposed to occupationally are “probably carcinogenic to humans.”
Hair Dyes and Health
If you have developed breast cancer or other cancer that you believe may be linked to hair dyes, or if you have experienced hair or scalp damage or other health problems related to hair dyes and hair relaxers, the attorneys at Parker Waichman LLP can advise you about your legal rights. To contact the firm, complete the form at the right or call 1-800-YOURLAWYER (1-800-968-7529).