Founding Partner
The recent decision in Adams v. Suffolk County from New York’s Second Department marks a pivotal moment in the legal landscape for victims of foster care abuse. The ruling establishes that municipal agencies owe a heightened duty to children in foster care, not just the general public. This duty, known as a “special duty,” arises when a municipality assumes legal custody of a child and undertakes responsibilities for their welfare, including placement and supervision within foster homes. The decision has significant implications for victims seeking justice. By recognizing that a municipal agency’s custodial relationship inherently creates a duty of care, the court has expanded the opportunities for survivors of abuse to hold public entities accountable for negligence. In this case, the plaintiff alleged that Suffolk County’s Department of Social Services (DSS) placed her in multiple foster homes during the 1970s where she endured sexual abuse by foster parents and neighbors. The court found that Suffolk County failed to meet its obligations to properly select and supervise foster homes, allowing these abuses to occur. Importantly, the court rejected the county’s arguments that the plaintiff needed to prove additional factors to establish liability. This ruling diverges from interpretations in the First and Fourth Departments, which have required plaintiffs to meet a stricter test known as the Cuffy factors to demonstrate a “special relationship.” The Second Department, however, determined that legal custody itself creates the requisite duty of care. This broader interpretation simplifies the legal process for victims of foster care negligence. Survivors no longer need to prove that a municipal agency made specific promises or induced reliance. Instead, the existence of legal custody is sufficient to establish liability, making this decision a powerful tool for those seeking accountability under laws like the Child Victims Act.
Municipal agencies often invoke governmental immunity to shield themselves from liability, arguing that their actions were discretionary rather than ministerial. This defense protects municipalities from lawsuits based on decisions that involve judgment or policy-making. However, the Second Department firmly rejected this defense in Adams v. Suffolk County. The court concluded that DSS’s actions in selecting and supervising foster parents were ministerial, not discretionary. Ministerial actions require adherence to established rules or standards, and failure to meet those standards can lead to liability. For example, DSS is expected to vet foster parents, ensure regular inspections, and address potential red flags during home visits. Suffolk County failed to provide evidence that its caseworkers followed these basic protocols, undermining its immunity argument. This distinction between discretionary and ministerial actions is crucial for victims pursuing claims against municipalities. When municipal employees fail to follow established guidelines, governmental immunity cannot protect their negligence. In this case, Suffolk County’s lack of oversight directly contributed to the plaintiff’s harm, eliminating immunity as a defense. By classifying foster care oversight as ministerial, the court has set a precedent that strengthens victims’ ability to challenge negligent practices in foster care systems. This decision underscores the responsibility of municipal agencies to meet their legal obligations when managing foster care placements.
The Adams v. Suffolk County decision is poised to have far-reaching consequences. Victims of foster care abuse now have a clearer path to hold municipalities accountable under the Child Victims Act. This law revived claims for child sexual abuse, allowing survivors to file lawsuits that were previously time-barred. With this decision, plaintiffs no longer need to navigate the complexities of proving a special relationship through the Cuffy factors. Instead, legal custody alone is sufficient to establish that a municipal agency owes a duty of care. This streamlined approach reduces the burden on survivors and creates new opportunities for accountability. The decision also increases the likelihood of future litigation against municipalities for systemic failures in foster care. Municipalities must now take proactive steps to improve oversight and compliance with legal standards to mitigate their exposure to liability. For survivors, this ruling is a powerful acknowledgment of the harm caused by negligent foster care practices and a pathway to seek justice.
Parker Waichman LLP
Our law firm is ready to represent you in your injury case. We’ve helped many New York residents as well as those needing help nationwide. Contact our team for a free case consultation today.
I had a great experience with them , everyone was very helpful and sweet.
Michelle Murphy
4 months ago
Zarahi was very professional and very Quick and very knowledgeable i realy appreciated her patience and perseverance she Deserves 100 stars 🌟 but since i can only send 5 i Guess i will just have to send that truly yours Rashine Downs
Kush Three
6 months ago
VERY NICE WORK PLACE THEY HAVE BEEN GOOD TO MY MOM
Whitney Brinson
5 years ago
They treated me with tender love and care
Terrell Weaver
2 months ago
Wonderful people. They made the whole process if dealing with a gov’t agency so easy. Special compliments to Gina Viti
Michael Ross
2 months ago
I’m a 9/11 first responder, and I can honestly say that Parker Waichman made me feel like they had my best interest in my VCF case. Ms Candalino & Ms Viti are top notch in my book. I was constantly informed on the status of my case. I would definitely recommend Parker Waichman LLP to family and friends.
D D
6 years ago
We have the experience and the skilled litigators to win your case. Contact us and speak with a real attorney who can help you.
Parker Waichman LLP
6 Harbor Park Drive
Port Washington, NY 11050
Parker Waichman LLP
201 Old Country Road – Suite 145
Melville, NY 11747
Parker Waichman LLP
300 Cadman Plaza West
One Pierrepont Plaza, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
Parker Waichman LLP
27299 Riverview Center Boulevard, Suite 108
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
We handle mass torts cases nationwide. Please contact our office to learn more.